To plan or not to plan?

May 24, 2016


Planning sucks.


Well for me anyway.


When I start a book, I’m a pantser all the way. A writer who just writes the scenes that come to them in no particular order.


But then it gets to a point where I should start assembling these scenes into a story line. So then that’s when I start to plan.


At first, it goes well. I plan out all my chapters, inserting the scenes I have written into each different chapter. Then I will try to come up with new scene ideas to fill in the plot holes and stitch the story together.


This is then the part I hate about planning. The new scenes that I need to write. I don’t hate writing the new scenes. But it’s like I’m pantsing all over again.


For example, at the moment I am working on my third novel. The original title was Daughter of the Sea. With the original story plan in place that title made perfect sense.



As I start writing out the new scenes, I realise that I have to move some of the existing scenes around.  Or when the new scenes are drafted they become a whole new chapter. So the preceding chapters then need to be re-organised.

Or the chapter becomes so large that it needs to be split into shorter chapters. Then re-written in parts so the new split chapters will read seamlessly.


So then my planning pages becomes messy. Whiting out chapter descriptions and re-writing the new ones. Changing the order of chapter numbers.


It all ends up looking like a dog’s breakfast.



There is also another problem I am facing with Daughter of the Sea's carefully laid out plan.  When I look at the plan, I realise that a pivotal scene cannot happen in just the one chapter that I had originally thought. The character’s decision that she needs to make, needs more of a lead up to it so that the reader can understand why.


So now the Daughter of the Sea, has a new title: The Queen’s Alliance and could possibly be split into two books. The series now being called “Daughters of the Sea”.


After a while, I began to realise I hated planning because of how I was doing my chapter plan.


I love to hand write my rough drafts (you can read all about that post here)


So I thought handwriting the chapter plans would also work. I was wrong.


It was my husband who suggested that I do it electronically.


Well I’ve heard Scrivener is good for that but a nightmare to learn. But then a thought occurred to me.


In my previous job, I was an Administration Officer. One task that I had to complete a lot of was creating spreadsheets on Excel.


So then it hit me. Why not do the chapter plans on Excel?


That way I could move the data cells around without using white out and post it notes. I could even add a running total of my word count in another column.





Yes, at first it was. But  again, I’m still having trouble with my story plan. Pushing chapters back and re-numbering previous chapters. I think my muse likes to torture me throwing new scenes at me all the time.


But I’ll stick to the Excel spreadsheet though. It is working out a lot better.


After all I do need some order for the chaos.



Please reload

Featured Posts

Book Research: Climbing a Mountain

April 26, 2016

Please reload

Recent Posts

January 17, 2018

April 18, 2016

April 5, 2016

April 5, 2016

Please reload

Please reload

Search By Tags
Please reload

Follow Us